Where every piece tells your story.

Featured Products

Silver bracelet with evenly spaced small diamonds around it.
Pair of silver hoop earrings with blue and clear gemstones.
Gold chain bracelet with oval and twisted links, clasped at the top.

Our Services & Expert Team

Appraisal’s- Jessica & Geneva

$75 Diamond

$95 Gemstone

Our GIA trained Graduate Gemologists are experienced in insurance appraisals as well as estate appraisals. We’ll prepare all of the paperwork you need and usually within 24-48 hours.

We recommend that you update your appraisals every 3-5 years depending upon market conditions.

Seven women dressed in black outfits, standing together indoors in front of a wooden display case with decorative items and photographs, smiling at the camera.

Jewelry Repair

Free Instant Quotes in-store.

All jewelry repairs are done on site by highly experienced bench jewelers. Our head jeweler Daniel has been in the industry for over 25 years and is an expert gold and silver smith.

Custom Jewelry

Free Quotes

Custom design is the forefront of our talent at Steffan’s Jewelers.

We believe that creating a piece of jewelry that is unique to you should not have excess cost attached to it.  We pride ourselves with offering custom design on all levels.  From the uniquely simple to elaborate and intense, we promise to make the entire process enjoyable and exciting.

Stop in to see what we can create for you.  All consultations & estimates for design are complimentary.

At Steffans jewelers, we deliver and employ the most professional services in the area

Schedule your appointment

Elkhorn Location:

262-398-4679

15 S. Wisconsin St. Elkhorn WI

McHenry Location:

815-385-6070

325 N. Front Street McHenry Il

Contact Us

Interested in working together? Fill out some info and we will be in touch shortly. We can’t wait to hear from you!

About Us

Steffan’s Jewelers has helped its customers celebrate life's most important relationships and significant events for over 78 years. As a fourth generation family owned jeweler, our store specializes in engagement rings, fine jewelry, watches, diamonds, gemstones, and expert in-house jewelry repair.

Our team of Fine Jewelry Consultants are trained to provide the highest level of personalized customer service, jewelry expertise and the latest fashions, trends, and jewelry knowledge.

You will find the Steffan’s experience is one of a kind.

Visit our expansive, luxury showroom today!

We look forward to becoming the family owned jeweler you can trust.

A group of six people, five women and one man, standing outside a jewelry store called Steffani's Jewelers, posing for a photo in black and white.

Follow us on social